Columbus, OH

Every Slice
Tells a Story.

Handcrafted pies baked with intention — flaky crusts, bold fillings, and recipes that turn a simple meal into a memory you carry home.

N High St
Columbus, OH
Fresh
Baked Daily
Local
Ingredients
Scroll
A baker rolling out pie dough by hand in a warm kitchen
Our Story

Born from a love of
real pie.

Pie of the Tiger started with a simple conviction: pie isn't a dessert afterthought — it's the main event. From our kitchen on North High Street, we craft every pie by hand using recipes that honor tradition while pushing past it.

We source locally when we can, bake fresh every day, and refuse to cut corners on crust, filling, or flavor. The result is a pie that doesn't just fill you up — it makes you stop and pay attention.

100%
Handmade from scratch
Daily
Fresh batches, never frozen
Visit Us

Come say
hello.

We're right on North High Street in the heart of Columbus. Walk in, grab a slice, or call ahead to save your favorite.

Address
674 N High St
Columbus, OH 43215-1547
Hours
Mon – Sat: 9:00 AM – 7:00 PM
Sunday: 10:00 AM – 5:00 PM

Your next favorite pie
is one call away.

Fresh-baked, handcrafted, and waiting for you on North High Street.

(380) 210-0197
Is this your business? Claim your website
Your own domain includedLive in minutes, edit anytime
Claim my website